Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Mini Rice Balls
Chicken Parmigiana 18"
Square Grandma Pie 18"
Extra Cheese 18"
About
Gencarelli’s Wayne
Welcome to Gencarelli’s Wayne, a culinary gem nestled in the heart of Wayne, NJ. Located at 58 Lake Dr W, this bustling eatery has garnered a reputation for not only delivering quality food but also for its outstanding customer service. Whether you're a local or just passing through, Gencarelli’s Wayne promises a dining experience that celebrates both tradition and taste.
As you stroll into Gencarelli’s, the first thing that captures your attention is the warm, inviting atmosphere. The aroma of deliciously prepared dishes wafts through the air, enticing even the most discerning food lover. Gencarelli's specializes in a variety of offerings, from vibrant salads to hearty appetizers. Notably, the Buffalo Shrimp Salad is a standout—large, satisfying, and perfectly paired with the tangy allure of buffalo sauce. If you’re in the mood for something special, the Mediterranean-infused Italian Antipasto showcases an array of flavors that transport you straight to Italy.
The appetizer menu, featuring favorites such as Buffalo Calamari and Stuffed Mushrooms, satisfies your cravings even before the main course arrives. A common theme among customers is the exceptional quality of the wings—crispy on the outside, juicy on the inside. Roseanna Scimone raves, "The wings are beyond amazing!" This level of quality is echoed by many who cherish the variety of options available for any genre of craving.
Gencarelli's Wayne shines in its main courses as well. Renowned dishes like the Lobster Ravioli have made waves, especially during special occasions. Taylor Kratzer shared her delight in finding this gem, stating it "absolutely exceeded expectations" with its fresh lobster and creamy sauce. The care put into each dish reflects a commitment to excellence that keeps patrons returning time and again.
Not only does Gencarelli's boast fantastic food, but it also offers convenience with services such as online ordering. This was particularly well-received by Jeanne F, whose large order was handled efficiently and delivered with care, bringing comfort during a challenging time.
The heart of Gencarelli’s Wayne lies not only in the vibrancy of the culinary experiences but also in its dedication to community. From family pizza nights, as the Ibrahim family champions, to well-crafted cakes for special occasions, Gencarelli's brings people together. Kitti Lakner’s birthday cake was a testament to the bakery’s skill, proving that their offerings extend well beyond savory dishes.
If you’re looking for an establishment that presents a fusion of flavors and a cozy ambiance, Gencarelli’s Wayne should be your next stop. From delicious salads to mouthwatering entrees, there’s something here for everyone, along with a very welcoming staff eager to make your dining experience unforgettable. Don’t forget to order online for a convenient discount! Immerse yourself in the world of Gencarelli’s and discover why it stands out as one of Wayne’s best eating establishments.
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ As an wing-lover, the wings are beyond amazing! They have are super crispy outside and really juicy and tender inside. We highly recommend!!!! You will want to order at least a half of tray because they'll be done in a minute! The vodka sauce pizza is equally as awesome! The sauce is so creamy, we can't get enough!! Great customer service, too!!! ”
“ Ordered a bunch of food for my birthday celebration during quarantine. The service was safe and efficient. The food was absolutely delicious! I had been looking all over specifically for lobster ravioli, and I was so lucky to find it here because it absolutely exceeded expectations. The lobster was fresh and the sauce was creamy and delicious. We also got chicken napoli, chicken francaise and 2 sandwiches. Not one complaint. Everything was cooked well and nothing came home cold! Really great experience and we will definitely be ordering again. ”
“ Love this place, great food, great prices and one of the best pizza places in Wayne NJ. Try their chicken noodle soup as well, always freshly made, always super tasty, and the bread served with it is mouth watering. My go to spot for a pizza night with the family. Make sure to order on their website to get 10 percent off and sign up for their Groupon to get another 10 percent off. You can’t beat the quality and price. ”
“ Wanted to place a large order on short notice. I placed the order online and was called within minutes to discuss a change due to short notice. The young lady who called was very helpful in addressing the timeframe and the item replacement. Food was delivered early, there were ample portions and recipients said it was delicious. Thank you for helping to comfort and feed our friends at a very difficult time. ”
“ They made a cake for my son's birthday. I had a full sheet cake and they did a killer job. Sure, I could have saved a little money if I got a Costco cake but I heard Gencarelli's had great tasting cakes... They did not disappoint. I will definitely use them again. ”
“ My wife found this place while trying to find a chicken saltimbocca recipe that didn’t have mushrooms. We thought what the heck and gave it a shot. I ordered the chicken vodka parm entree and OH MY GOODNESS it was amazing. It was one of the best meals I have ever had in my life. The pizza we ordered for our kids was excellent if you like the thin crust type. 10/10 would get again. ”
“ I have been ordering from here for years !! The food is always top notch.. I also have had them cater birthdays and other events for me, delivery drivers always arrived and set up the food !! Pizza too , great options a lot of variety to make everyone happy. I have always been given great service over the last 15 years from front end staff to delivery drivers... VC ”
“ I had the drunken grandma pizza pie deal for 17 and upon tasting it, I knew right away this was the best around. The combination between the crust the cheese and the vodka sauce the balance was absolutely perfect. The texture was crunchy on the outside and cooked to perfection on the inside. I had about a 15 minute wait once I arrived but it was well worth the wait. Perfection isn’t instant. ”